Home

Home2026-05-06T22:07:17+03:00

Not What You Thought

By |October 21st, 2026|Categories: Rav's Blog|Tags: , |

“This is My covenant, which you shall keep, between Me and you and your children after you; Every male among you shall be circumcised.” (Bereishis 17:10) Rav Shlomo Hyman (1892-1944), the Rosh Yeshiva of Torah Vodaath, related the following story: Rav Shlomo Kluger (1785–1869), the [...]

לא כפי שחשבתם

By |October 21st, 2026|Categories: הבלג של הרב|Tags: , |

זֹאת בְּרִיתִי אֲשֶׁר תִּשְׁמְרוּ בֵּינִי וּבֵינֵיכֶם וּבֵין זַרְעֲךָ אַחֲרֶיךָ הִמּוֹל לָכֶם כׇּל־זָכָר׃(בראשית יז:י) רב שלמה היימן, ראש ישיבת תורה ודעת, סיפר את הסיפור הבא: רבי שלמה קלוגר, רבה בפועל של העיר ברודי, נהג להציב בקשה מיוחדת בכל פעם שהתבקש לשמש כסנדק בברית מילה. הוא היה [...]

Rabbi Avrohom Baruch Zachariash teaches the halachos of Breaking Bread with the Mishnah Berurah (O.C. 166-167)

AI Summary:
Hand Washing Halachic Discussion
The Rav discussed the halachic question of who should wash hands last before a meal, exploring whether it should be someone who is more righteous or someone who is less likely to transgress. He argued that the halacha should consider the greater good and the person who is more likely to maintain proper behavior, rather than focusing solely on avoiding gaps between washing and eating. The discussion touched on practical considerations about who might be more suitable for this role based on their character and likelihood of following proper procedures.

Independent Task Performance Discussion
The Rav discussed the importance of individuals performing tasks independently rather than collectively, using the example of making bread and bottles. He shared a story about a bris scheduling decision, explaining that while early morning ceremonies have historical significance, practical considerations like family attendance should take precedence. The Rav noted that bris scheduling practices have evolved over time, with some traditions changing after historical events like the Holocaust.

Bris Timing Discussion
The discussion focused on the question of whether a bris should be performed in the afternoon to avoid having people wait, with considerations about family size and logistics. The participants discussed the timing of handwashing for the bris, noting that the entire process takes about a minute and a half, and concluded that most families could manage the waiting time. The group also addressed concerns about children being quiet during the ceremony and determined that a brief period of waiting would be acceptable.

Challah Slicing and Blessing Practices
The Rav discussed halachic practices around bread slicing and blessings, particularly focusing on the proper way to slice challah before and after meals. He explained that challah should be sliced from the side while attached, and that different types of bread braided together remain separate items even when connected. The Rav shared a personal story about questioning his mother-in-law's practice of blessing mixed-bread braids and concluded that the breads remain separate unless actually blended together. Halachas of Breaking Bread 166-167 - Zachariash (1)

Halachas of Breaking Bread 166-167 - Zachariash (1)

Beis Medrash Ahavas Shalom October 20, 2026 21:38

Rabbi Avrohom Baruch Zachariash teaches the halachos of washing hands with the Mishnah Berurah (O.C. 165)

AI Summary:
Religious Meal and Cleanliness Program
The transcript appears to contain fragmented speech and incomplete thoughts, making it difficult to determine a clear topic or conclusion. The discussion seems to touch on a religious or cultural program involving meal practices and spiritual cleanliness, but specific details are unclear due to the disjointed nature of the conversation.

Food Handling and Meal Protocols
The Rav discussed a halachic concept about touching food after sweating and the importance of maintaining clean hands during meals. He provided an example of a scenario where someone becomes so engrossed in conversation that they lose focus on being present at the meal, leading to potential issues with proper observance of mealtime protocols.

Mental Engagement in Family Activities
The Rav discussed the phenomenon of people being physically present at meals or activities but mentally disengaged, using examples like reading books during meals or wearing earbuds on family trips. He explained the difference between parents and children's perspectives on family travel, noting that parents value the bonding time of the journey itself while children focus only on reaching the destination.

Cognitively Present During Religious Observances
The Rav discussed a scenario where someone was using a phone while walking down a hospital aisle, highlighting how technology is becoming more common in everyday situations. He emphasized the importance of being cognizantly present and aware of one's actions, particularly during religious observances like washing hands after certain activities. The Rav stressed that intention alone is not sufficient and that people must be actively aware of their actions and surroundings.

Hand-Washing and Hygiene Requirements
The Rav discussed the requirements for hand-washing, explaining that touching potentially contaminating objects is problematic, while touching gloves or someone else's hands is not. He asked questions about whether people are aware when they park their shoes or tie them during dancing, suggesting people may not be attentive to these actions. The Rav also shared a personal anecdote about leaving a Shabbos meal early due to disagreeing with conversational topics about cars and travel, choosing instead to learn on the couch.

Shabbos Advertisements Permissibility Discussion
The Rav discussed the permissibility of looking at advertisements for products in different locations, particularly when considering purchases that would require someone to bring items from another country. He explained that while there is no halachic prohibition against looking at such advertisements, it is not a normal practice and would only be justified in specific circumstances, such as urgent need or significant savings. The Rav clarified that the discussion was about whether it is permissible to engage in such conversations at a Shabbos table, distinguishing between discussing products of interest versus making actual purchases.

Shabbos Hosting and Talmudic Debates
The Rav discussed strategies for hosting non-religious companies during Shabbos, emphasizing the importance of advance preparation to meet guests' needs. He shared a personal example of preparing specific spiritual support (chizuk) for each of his six children during a Seder. The discussion then shifted to a complex Talmudic debate about how the people of Zion were punished for not performing acts of kindness, with The Rav explaining Rishainim and Ahrainim perspectives on individual versus group avera (transgressions) and the unique severity of legislating against chesed.

Rabbi Teaching Qualifications Discussion
The Rav discussed a question about whether an unmarried Balestruba could serve as a teacher, sharing a story about how the Rebbe Kovner would have students answer halachic questions in his absence and review them upon his return. The Rav emphasized that every question asked of a rabbi is an opportunity to bring people closer to Hashem, as taught by Rav Okonka, and that the role of a rabbi extends beyond answering halachic questions to spiritual guidance.

Handwashing Guidelines for Meals
The Rav discussed halachic guidelines about handwashing during meals, focusing on when and how to wash hands properly. He explained that if a person needs to use the bathroom during a meal, they should go immediately rather than delaying, and must wash their hands before making the Asher Yatzar blessing. The discussion covered specific scenarios including wearing hats with leather bands, beards, and sweat considerations, with The Rav providing practical examples and clarifications about proper handwashing procedures. Halachas of Washing Hands 165 - Zachariash (12)

Halachas of Washing Hands 165 - Zachariash (12)

Beis Medrash Ahavas Shalom October 13, 2026 21:41

Rabbi Avrohom Baruch Zachariash teaches the halachos of washing hands with the Mishnah Berurah (O.C. 165)

AI Summary:
Halachic Hand Washing Requirements
The Rav discussed the halachic requirements for hand washing, particularly in the morning and before meals. The Rav explained that while some traditions suggest washing hands once in the morning is sufficient, this may not align with strict halachic requirements, which depend on the timing of meals and proper intention during washing. They also discussed challenges with modern editions of Torah texts lacking comprehensive commentary from earlier authorities, and briefly touched on the concept of washing hands in specific situations like air travel.
Bathroom Plumbing and Brachas Discussion
The Rav discussed the technical aspects of bathroom plumbing and shared a personal story about davening on a plane. He explained that while davening sitting down is considered a bidieved according to Mishnah Brura, he has done it multiple times on planes when the situation called for it, particularly when standing would attract attention. The Rav also raised a question about making brachas while knowing one will eat later, noting that once out of the parsha, one must eat before making brachas.
Halachic Hand Washing Discussion
The Rav discussed halachic questions about hand washing for different purposes, explaining that one must wash hands with the specific intention of preparing for a particular activity like davening or eating. He addressed the question of whether prayer rooms in airports or other non-traditional spaces are appropriate for davening, expressing discomfort with certain locations and explaining that the status of a space as a shul depends on consistent use for religious purposes. The discussion also covered practical questions about when hand washing is required, including situations involving food in the mouth and exposure of body parts typically covered by clothing. Halachas of Washing Hands 165 - Zachariash (11)

Halachas of Washing Hands 165 - Zachariash (11)

Beis Medrash Ahavas Shalom October 6, 2026 21:51

Rabbi Avrohom Baruch Zachariash teaches the halachos of Sitting in teh Sukkah with the Mishnah Berurah (O.C. 640)

AI Summary:
Children's Independence and Care Responsibilities
The discussion focused on questions about when children can be left alone or start certain responsibilities, with participants debating different age thresholds. The conversation touched on whether a hospital patient should have someone present to monitor their care, with one participant explaining that while a supervisor might be assigned to ensure proper care, they wouldn't handle medical tasks like feeding or administering medication. The discussion also referenced Jewish legal texts regarding obligations for babysitting and care responsibilities.

Political Engagement and Responsiveness
The speaker discussed the importance of knowing when and how much to be involved in political or community matters, using an anecdote about being called to the hospital to illustrate the point about responding appropriately to different people's requests. They explained that in a political situation involving Nasrin Ali and Bashar Daud, both individuals were needed despite potentially overlapping roles because the way one responds and acts depends on who is making the request. The speaker concluded by referencing a historical filibuster that occurred before an event called Shalia.

Guest Hosting and Attention Levels
The discussion centered around a story involving a situation where someone was planning to leave but decided to stay after guests arrived. The speaker shared experiences about hosting guests and the appropriate level of attention required, noting that in most situations guests can be comfortable without constant supervision. The conversation also touched on a specific incident involving someone at a hospital who had to stay throughout a designated time period.

Sukkot Observance and Requirements
The discussion focused on various aspects of Sukkot observance, including sleeping in sukkahs, using air conditioners, and traveling during the holiday. The participants discussed whether people are obligated to sleep in sukkahs and shared personal experiences about sleeping arrangements during Sukkot. They also addressed questions about eating in temporary sukkahs, particularly when traveling, and debated the halachic requirements around wine storage and worker supervision during Sukkot. Halachas of Sitting in the Sukkah

Halachas of Sitting in the Sukkah

Beis Medrash Ahavas Shalom September 22, 2026 22:02

Rabbi Avrohom Baruch Zachariash teaches the halachos of Rosh Hashanah with the Mishnah Berurah (O.C. 582, 583, and 592)

AI Summary:

Prayer Mistake Halachic Practices
The Rav discussed halachic practices regarding mistakes during prayer, particularly focusing on different types of errors and their acceptance. They explained that while some mistakes are tolerated due to being on "autopilot," others involving incorrect words are not accepted. The Rav noted that there are specific rules about mistakes on Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, though most people disagree with these concepts both in terms of halachic reasoning and practical application.

Shabbat vs Yom Tov Blessings
The Rav discussed the differences between blessings for Shabbat and Yom Tov, specifically focusing on the unique blessings said during Pesach and Tzepis. He explained that certain blessings are specific to Shabbat only and should not be mentioned during Yom Tov, citing examples from the Racha main Shava where "hamelech" is said on Shabbat but not on Yom Tov. The Rav emphasized that these distinctions are based on serious halachic principles about what constitutes part of the nusach (text) versus additional insertions, and he connected this discussion to upcoming blessings that will be said soon.

Rosh Hashanah Pronunciation and Practices
The Rav discussed the proper pronunciation and observance of Rosh Hashanah, explaining that the subject is alluded to rather than explicitly mentioned. He addressed the concept of davening aloud in different settings and the importance of considering how one's prayers might affect others. The Rav also touched on the practice of eating semanim and shared a story about the sensitive nature of certain religious practices during the beginning of the year.

Rosh Hashanah Traditions and Expectations
The Rav discussed the importance of not getting annoyed with others when expectations are not met, sharing a story about Rabbi Greenberg and emphasizing that disappointment depends on one's expectations. He explained traditions around Rosh Hashanah foods, including the symbolism of eating sweet foods and avoiding sharp or sour items, and discussed the practice of eating specific foods like apples and honey. The Rav also addressed questions about whether certain foods like grapes and sourdough bread are permitted during the holiday and explained different opinions on when the mitzvah of eating maror is performed during the Seder. Halachas of Rosh Hashanah (5)

Halachas of Rosh Hashanah (5)

Beis Medrash Ahavas Shalom September 8, 2026 21:35

Rabbi Avrohom Baruch Zachariash teaches the halachos of blowing the Shofar with the Mishnah Berurah (O.C. 591)

AI Summary:

Hidden Kavanah in Jewish Practice
The discussion focused on explaining a hidden kavanah in Jewish religious practice, specifically discussing how certain prayers and rituals are omitted during times when there is no moon. The speaker explained that while these elements are not explicitly mentioned in the Mishnah, they are not forgotten entirely but are alluded to through other references, such as when mentioning different kavanot (intention) for offerings.

Hilches Rosh Chodesh Prayer Discussion
The speaker discussed an important halacha from Hilches Rosh Chodesh regarding the Token of the Corbin Mussel of Harambe Tsoka, explaining that when saying the morning prayers, certain elements are alluded to without being explicitly mentioned, including Rosh Chodesh. The discussion touched on the proper pronunciation and structure of certain prayers, with the speaker noting some uncertainty about the exact correct formulation. The speaker also mentioned being previously disturbed by the order of certain prayer elements but chose not to get involved in debating the details.

Religious Practices and Priorities
The discussion centered around concepts related to religious practices and their importance, with particular focus on the relationship between different elements within religious observances. The speaker shared a personal experience about attending services after a birth, which led to reflections on how time is allocated during religious activities and whether certain components are prioritized appropriately. The conversation touched on the concept of interrelatedness in religious practices and the question of which elements are essential versus optional, with specific reference to the legacy of Yitzchak and his children.

Halachic Principles of Prayer
The discussion focused on halachic principles regarding prayer and judgment, particularly addressing scenarios where someone might find themselves in isolated situations. The speaker explained concepts about proper prayer procedures and emphasized that individuals should not daven alone, citing examples from traditional texts including stories about Rebbi Akiva. The conversation explored various legal interpretations about when and how certain religious practices should be performed, with particular attention to concepts of "Emes" and proper prayer requirements in different situations.

Rosh Hashanah and Spiritual Challenges
The discussion focused on the concept of Rosh Hashanah and the significance of being willing to face challenges or judgment in order to maintain a relationship with a higher authority, even though it may come at a personal cost. The speaker referenced a previous discussion from 10 years ago about this concept and explained that while the daily application might be less intense than other contexts, it still applies regularly. The conversation concluded with a discussion about prayer timing, particularly regarding whether the practice should be different this year compared to the first day of Shabbos.

Selichos and Religious Practices
The discussion focused on Selichos arrangements, with clarification that no dinner would be held on Shabbos due to it being a baker's holiday. The speaker emphasized that there is a proper time for everything and that people should not rush to complete tasks before their appropriate time. The conversation also touched on cultural differences in religious practices, comparing Sephardi traditions where the same prayers are recited daily to the more varied practices of other communities.

Religious Requirements for Leadership Roles
The discussion focused on religious requirements and qualifications for specific roles, particularly regarding who should serve as a Chazen. The speaker emphasized that while there are certain qualifications mentioned, the most important requirement is that the person should be someone who prays regularly. The conversation also touched on the importance of having appropriate representatives and avoiding potential problems by using regular procedures when possible.

Community Leadership Dispute Discussion
The speaker discussed a community leadership dispute involving a position where someone was asked to be a vocal candidate but had previously been replaced by another person. They explained that a letter was written stating the original candidate had no claim to the position, though it didn't explicitly mention being terminated. The speaker also shared insights about Yom Kippur customs, including discussions about when to take haircuts and whether one can say certain prayers at home if there's no minyan at the synagogue. Halachas of Blowing the Shofar O.C. 591 (4)

Halachas of Blowing the Shofar O.C. 591 (4)

Beis Medrash Ahavas Shalom September 1, 2026 21:18

Go to Top